Rebooting AI
Building Artificial Intelligence We Can Trust
Synopsis
Gary Marcus, a cognitive scientist, and Ernest Davis, a computer scientist who studies commonsense reasoning, argue that headline AI achievements such as winning a television quiz show or mastering Go came in closed domains with fixed rules and do not show that general, trustworthy intelligence is near. They describe a gap between what AI is said to do and what it reliably does, illustrating it with brittle image classifiers, machine reading systems that match patterns without grasping meaning, and robots that cannot cope with the open-ended disorder of an ordinary home. Deep learning, in their account, is a powerful tool for perception and classification but an incomplete foundation for understanding.
The authors propose a different path drawn from cognitive science: systems that combine learning with explicit knowledge, represent time, space and causality, and reason about the world as people do. Written for general readers, the book uses everyday examples, such as the background knowledge needed to follow a short passage from a children's novel, to show how much understanding humans bring to simple tasks. Published in 2019, it predates large language models, yet many of its tests for robustness and reasoning remain contested. Readers gain a clear framework for judging AI claims and asking whether a system understands or merely correlates.
Scorecard
Editorial score
How it scored
Editorial score: 70.8 / 1005 weighted criteria
- 22.5/30
Influence30%
- 20.0/25
Authority25%
- 12.0/20
Practical value20%
- 8.3/15
Currency15%
- 8.0/10
Readability10%
- 70.8/100
Editorial score
How the rank was computed
Rank No. 127 of 500 comes from a composite of 61.1: observable signals 29.3 of 55 points plus editorial review 31.8 of 45 points.
All 11 inputs
| Input | Points |
|---|---|
| Observable signals | 29.3/55 |
| Reach (Amazon ratings volume) | 9.6/16.5 |
| Consensus across best-of lists | 13.8/13.8 |
| Awards and bestseller evidence | 0.0/8.3 |
| Reader rating, sample-adjusted | 5.4/8.3 |
| Amazon sales rank | 0.5/5.5 |
| Recency | 0.0/2.8 |
| Editorial review | 31.8/45 |
| Author authority | 9.0/11.3 |
| Influence | 10.1/13.5 |
| Practical value | 5.4/9.0 |
| Readability | 3.6/4.5 |
| Currency | 3.7/6.8 |
Each criterion is scored from 1 to 10 and weighted, and the points add up to the editorial score. The rank combines observable signals (55 percent) with this score (45 percent). Read the methodology.
Verdict
A lucid pre-ChatGPT critique of deep learning's limits whose case for common sense and reasoning still frames debates about reliable AI.
Strengths
- Clear, jargon-light critique of deep learning
- Concrete examples of AI failure modes
- Grounded in cognitive science and commonsense reasoning research
Keep in mind
Because it predates ChatGPT, some of its examples of AI failure have been partly overtaken, and readers wanting a neutral survey will find it argumentative.
Key takeaways
- Impressive results in games and benchmarks often reflect closed, rule-bound settings and do not transfer to the open-ended real world.
- Statistical pattern matching without models of objects, time, space and causality leaves AI brittle when inputs differ from its training data.
- Trustworthy AI likely requires hybrid systems that combine machine learning with structured knowledge and explicit reasoning, informed by cognitive science.
- Judging an AI system means testing whether it understands a situation, not just whether it produces plausible outputs on familiar examples.
Notable facts
- Endorsed by former world chess champion Garry Kasparov, Harvard psychologist Steven Pinker, former MIT CSAIL director Rodney Brooks and MIT economist Erik Brynjolfsson. Source (opens in a new tab)
About the author
Questions
What does Rebooting AI argue?
Is Rebooting AI outdated after ChatGPT?
Who should read Rebooting AI?
Related books
Sources
As an Amazon Associate, Best AI Books earns from qualifying purchases. Best AI Books is sponsored by Iternal.ai, whose founder and CEO, John Byron Hanby IV, wrote The AI Strategy Blueprint, our #1 ranked book. How we rank books.






