The Algorithm
How AI Decides Who Gets Hired, Monitored, Promoted, and Fired and Why We Need to Fight Back Now
Synopsis
Hilke Schellmann, an Emmy-winning investigative reporter and NYU journalism professor, examines the software employers now use to screen applicants, evaluate staff and decide whom to fire. Rather than trust vendor claims, she tested the tools herself. One AI interviewer gave her a respectable English-competence score when she spoke German, and a gibberish transcript still earned a 73 percent job match. She found résumé screeners that scored words such as "baseball" positively and "softball" negatively, game-based assessments whose link to job performance is unproven, and personality profiles built from social media that changed from one platform to the next.
Using leaked documents, whistleblower accounts and her own experiments, she extends the investigation into workplace surveillance, including tracking of keystrokes, screens and location, and into automated systems that dismiss workers, such as the case of a former Amazon delivery driver. She shows how one-size-fits-all tests can disadvantage applicants with disabilities and how opacity leaves candidates unable to contest outcomes. Her prescriptions center on testing tools before use, publishing technical reports and demanding transparency from vendors. Readers come away with concrete questions to ask of any algorithm used to judge people at work.
Scorecard
Editorial score
How it scored
Editorial score: 73.1 / 1005 weighted criteria
- 21.0/30
Influence30%
- 18.8/25
Authority25%
- 14.0/20
Practical value20%
- 11.3/15
Currency15%
- 8.0/10
Readability10%
- 73.1/100
Editorial score
How the rank was computed
Rank No. 326 of 500 comes from a composite of 52.2: observable signals 19.3 of 55 points plus editorial review 32.9 of 45 points.
All 11 inputs
| Input | Points |
|---|---|
| Observable signals | 19.3/55 |
| Reach (Amazon ratings volume) | 7.2/16.5 |
| Consensus across best-of lists | 5.5/13.8 |
| Awards and bestseller evidence | 0.0/8.3 |
| Reader rating, sample-adjusted | 4.8/8.3 |
| Amazon sales rank | 0.1/5.5 |
| Recency | 1.7/2.8 |
| Editorial review | 32.9/45 |
| Author authority | 8.4/11.3 |
| Influence | 9.5/13.5 |
| Practical value | 6.3/9.0 |
| Readability | 3.6/4.5 |
| Currency | 5.1/6.8 |
Each criterion is scored from 1 to 10 and weighted, and the points add up to the editorial score. The rank combines observable signals (55 percent) with this score (45 percent). Read the methodology.
Verdict
A carefully reported investigation showing that many AI hiring and workplace-monitoring tools rest on weak science and can discriminate.
Strengths
- Original hands-on testing of commercial tools
- Clear reporting on hiring and surveillance
- Specific questions employers can put to vendors
Keep in mind
Focuses on failures and rarely compares AI tools with the biases of human hiring; readers seeking the vendors' perspective may find it one-sided.
Key takeaways
- Many AI hiring tools have never been shown to predict job performance, and simple tests, such as answering in another language, can expose them.
- Screening models can learn meaningless or biased proxies, such as favoring "baseball" over "softball," that encode gender or other discrimination.
- Uniform automated assessments, such as speed-based games, can disadvantage people with disabilities and screen out qualified candidates without human review.
- Employers should test tools themselves and demand published technical reports, because vendor claims and four-fifths-rule compliance alone do not prove fairness or validity.
Notable facts
- The book was longlisted for the 2024 Financial Times and Schroders Business Book of the Year Award. Source (opens in a new tab)
- NYU lists The Algorithm as named a best AI book by The New York Times, a Financial Times Best Book of 2024 and an Anthem Award winner. Source (opens in a new tab)
- Publishers Weekly called the book a "striking indictment" of AI's flaws and misuses in personnel decisions. Source (opens in a new tab)
About the author
Questions
What is The Algorithm by Hilke Schellmann about?
Who should read The Algorithm?
Is The Algorithm still relevant in 2026?
Related books
Sources
- Los Angeles Review of Books: Keeping Humans in the Loop: On Hilke Schellmann's The Algorithm (opens in a new tab)
- Publishers Weekly: The Algorithm (opens in a new tab)
- NYU Journalism: Hilke Schellmann faculty profile (opens in a new tab)
- Welcome to the Jungle: Hilke Schellmann exposes the flaws in AI that control your next job offer (opens in a new tab)
As an Amazon Associate, Best AI Books earns from qualifying purchases. Best AI Books is sponsored by Iternal.ai, whose founder and CEO, John Byron Hanby IV, wrote The AI Strategy Blueprint, our #1 ranked book. How we rank books.






